DEWALT DCD791 vs Makita XFD17: Which Drill Should You Buy?

NOTE: THIS IS DEMO/SAMPLE CONTENT FOR THE DOWNSIDE PRODUCT REVIEW SITE.

When choosing a premium compact drill, the DEWALT DCD791 and Makita XFD17 frequently emerge as the top contenders. Both represent the pinnacle of 18V/20V brushless motor technology for general-purpose drilling and driving, targeting serious DIYers and professional contractors who need a reliable daily driver. However, beneath their similar specifications, these tools prioritize very different user experiences, and choosing between them comes down to a clear understanding of their respective downsides.

The DEWALT DCD791 is an absolute powerhouse. In our torque testing, it consistently pushed heavy fasteners through dense material with less motor hesitation than the Makita. Its build quality feels marginally more robust, with heavy-duty rubber overmolding that can survive severe job site abuse. The downside is the weight and bulk. At 3.5 lbs bare, it is noticeably heavier than the Makita, which leads to quicker fatigue during overhead tasks. Furthermore, DEWALT’s battery ecosystem, while excellent, tends to carry a higher price premium, meaning the overall cost of ownership is steeper if you aren’t already invested in their platform.

Conversely, the Makita XFD17 prioritizes ergonomics and agility. It is significantly lighter and more compact, making it a joy to use in cramped cabinets or during long days of repetitive tasks. The trigger response and speed control are incredibly refined. Its downside lies in its raw top-end power. While perfectly adequate for 95% of tasks, it occasionally struggles on extreme high-torque applications where the DEWALT effortlessly pushes through. Additionally, Makita’s battery design, while reliable, hasn’t evolved as rapidly as competitors, lacking the newer high-output cell technologies found in some rival lines.

Ultimately, your choice depends on the work you do. If raw durability and maximum power are non-negotiable, and you don’t mind a heavier tool, the DEWALT DCD791 is the superior workhorse. But if you value ergonomics, lighter weight for extended use, and a slightly more approachable entry price, the Makita XFD17 is the smarter investment.